Terry Brooks
by Salman A. Nensi
Terry Brooks was a small town lawyer for 17 years. He had always wanted to be a writer but knew that it was practically impossible to make a living and raise a family on what you make as a writer. So, he studied law and began to practice while writing in the evening. With over ten books and three million copies in print, Terry Brooks is one of the most successful fantasy writers of our time. The Tangle Box, the fourth book in the Magic Kingdom series will be published in hardcover this April by Del Rey Books.
S: Let’s talk about being a lawyer—it was a long time ago…
T: What a scary thought. It was a long time ago and I’ve almost blotted it from my memory.
S: Try and think back.
T: I was in a small town practice—a five member firm of general practitioners. We took whatever walked through the door on any given day. You pretty much got to see the beginning and end of things and I liked that aspect of practicing law quite a bit. There was not so much delayed gratification and you really could work with people on a one to one basis, and usually do some good for them. I did it for l7 years and for most of that l7 years I enjoyed it. Towards the end I started to have a conflict between the writing and the practice, which hurt my enthusiasm for the law somewhat because I was always going to be a writer first and foremost. Also there were quite a few changes in the nature of practicing law that bothered me. It became a great deal more paperwork and there was an awful lot of new legislation. It became difficult to do a general practitioner’s work.
S: You were a lawyer, now you’re a successful writer. John Grisham was also a lawyer as was William Deverall… is there something about being a lawyer that gives one an insight into the human condition that aids in writing?
T: I think you could make that argument. Certainly you work with people who are under a lot of stress and who are dealing with very real and difficult problems. I think, you tend to see the best and the worst of people in those conditions and that`s a good thing for a writer. It is inspirational in a lot of ways, I think, because of that. I don’t think it is a particularly good profession for the mechanics of writing, however. Legal writing tends to be extremely stilted and not very innovative. That’s not particularly good for a writer of fiction to become immersed in. You could argue that the one balances the other out. I used to make that argument all the time to keep my sanity. I would practice law and I would be in the real world and I could go home and write fantasy and get away from all that. I’d take from a little bit of one into the other. Then there was the other argument. I used to go to talks and people would say, `how come a lawyer writes fantasies, isn’t that different’ and I’d say, well no, very much the same.
Both professions involve people who are wordsmiths. If you are a trial lawyer, for example, which I was, and I think Grisham was and Scott Turrow and maybe Deverall too… If words are your tools I think you certainly can see the way that would carry over to being a writer. Much of being a lawyer is putting together the puzzle, of working thoughts and concepts and logic through and reasoning out ideas. There is a lot that carries over between the two professions.

S: Let’s jump ahead a little. You finished your first Shannara book and sent it off to Del Rey. Somebody picked up the phone and called you and you were a star.
T: Not exactly. It was a little more complex than that. I actually submitted it the first time to Daw Publishing. Don Walheim had it 6 or 8 months. We exchanged a couple of letters. He was interested but he sent it back at the end and said it was too big and too risky but he liked the story and thought it would find a home and why didn’t I send it to Judy Lynn Del Rey over at Ballantine books who had just come in as science fiction editor. Of course I did, along with Don Walheim’s letter and it got there just as she was making a pitch to have Lester, her husband, hired as fantasy editor. When the book came in she took a look at it (I found all this out years later, I didn’t know any of it at the time) and she said 800 pages, what do I know, Lester look at this see if it is worth anything. Lester got hold of it and he liked it so much that when he went into accept the job he said he’d take the job if they’d let him publish this as his first book, under the Del Rey imprint. They agreed. Then Lester wrote me a letter. He did an interesting thing. In his first paragraph he said this is potentially the best work of fantasy since Tolken’s Lord of the Rings. That was the carrot. Then for the next four of five paragraphs he described the amount of work that I was going to have to do in order to make it an acceptable piece of fiction. That was just the beginning. He was a very tough, hard editor, but that was the beginning and it was very exciting to an unpublished, no nothing writer from the midwest.
S: They still look through the slush pile at Del Rey…
T: Oh yeah, they do. They do it at a number of publishing houses, but they have a real commitment to it at Del Rey. I go up there all the time and they’ve still got stacks and stacks of unpublished manuscripts sitting around. They go through them and occasionally they will find somebody. They still publish the Del Rey Discovery series as part of their program to promote new authors, authors they feel haven’t gotten significant recognition and need a little extra push.
S: With your first book Lester gave you a lot of direction.
T: Yes, he helped with every book I wrote, less so in the latter years for various reasons. Hopefully because I had learned some lessons.
S: I have a copy of the manuscript here for The Tangle Box and there are very few editing marks on it at all.
T: Well you know I have been lucky enough, he says knocking on wood, not to have had a significant rewrite on any book since Wishsong. That is about 7 books back.
S: Is that because your talent has been crafted? Is it a question of working out 3 or 4 books and finally getting to that stage where you know what the editor wants before the editor gets it?
T: Some of it is definitely a progressive kind of thing. I was heavily, heavily edited on the first 3 books that I wrote in the Shannara series. I did an extensive rewrite on Sword, rewrites that went on for a long period of time. The next book I submitted, which was a Shannara sequel, Lester Del Rey turned down, just flat turned it down. But he also did a page by page analysis of why the book didn’t work. I rewrote it for Elfstones, submitted Elfstones and he made me rewrite the middle 200 pages of Elfstones from scratch. I did a huge amount of rewriting in those first couple of books and I learned an awful lot about what it takes to be a nuts & bolts kind of writer. I think a lot of those lessons were learned early on fortunately and certainly they are the kind of lessons you don’t forget easily. I have been able to avoid a lot of the pitfalls that you might otherwise fall into and that’s been, I think, increasingly true as the books have gone on. You hope you retain some of what you have learned early.
The other thing is that I do all my work by submitting an outline first. The editor looks at what the outline is, sees the story, gets a description of the characters, gets an overview of what the story is supposed to accomplish and what it is going to do because I do both a chapter by chapter and a story synopsis. We talk it out and we go back and forth on it and we hash out most of the potential problems up front and I think that saves an awful lot on rewrites as well.
S: Can you describe the difference between Lester’s style and Owen’s [Owen Lock, Del Rey’s editor-in-chief] style?
T: Oh I think so. Lester was extremely opinionated and had some very hard and fast rules. He had a lifetime’s experience behind him when I met him—as a writer in the field of science fiction principally, as a critic and as an editor. He had been around for 40 years in the field when he started with me. Owen’s been in the field the same length of time I have which is about l6 to l8 years, as an editor. Owen is a much more easy going personality. He’s my contemporary, we kind of grew up in the business together. We are close friends, so ours is more of an equals friendship kind of relationship, whereas Lester was always more of a father figure. I was much more careful about crossing Lester. I held him in a great deal of awe and the relationship was considerably different because of where we had both come from. That relationship changed things completely. Both ways work and I was fortunate that I had Lester early on because I probably needed that kind of an editor in the beginning—somebody who you wouldn’t question. If he says it’s so it’s so and you would just do it because he had the experience and I didn’t. Now after having had that exposure I think it is better for me to have somebody like Owen that I am more comfortable working with. We exchange ideas and we talk back and forth and neither of us pulls any punches and I think that kind of helps.

S: The Sword of Shannara was the first fiction book to hit the New York Times Trade Paperback bestseller list. Two very successful Shannara books followed that. All of a sudden, Magic Kingdom. Where did the impetus for something different come from?
T: Well, it was a combination of things. After I wrote Wishsong I had at that point more than l0 years of writing Shannara books and I was fed up to the teeth with them. I really couldn’t do another one and do it justice. I told Lester that I had to write something else and he said well you should anyway and this is as good a time as any. I asked him if he had any ideas. I said I wanted to write something that is shorter. Something that is related in some way to to the contemporary world and that has more humor to it. He said, I do have an idea but I don’t think you are the right writer for it. Finally I beat him down and he told me what the idea was and it was the skeleton of the Magic Kingdom book. Lester said he’d give me the idea for a year and if I developed it and wrote it it’d be mine. Otherwise I’d have to give it back. I took it home and worked it over but he had envisioned it as being sort of a Piers Anthony Xanth kind of story. I’m not really built to do anything that involves puns and that much humor in a book, that was too much for me, I’m always looking for the dark side of it. So I said, well what can I do with this, what’s this book about? It was about a lawyer, who gave up his practice, bought this magic kingdom and then found out it wasn’t all what it was cracked up to be but it was still a challenge that was significant enough that he wanted to stay with it. I decided what this book was really about was my transition from becoming a lawyer to becoming a writer. So I used that as the metaphorical underpinnings of the book and sat down to figure out how it could be developed after that. That started the whole philosophy of the idea of Ben Holliday on the one hand as King and the power of his alter ego on the other.
S: Who then is your alter ego if you are Ben Holliday?
T: Well I have both of those sides in me. I have both the creator and the destroyer sides. I guess as a writer and you are always warring them with the two, I think, in some ways because there is a certain self-destructive bent to anyone who wants to be a writer anyway. (laughter)
S: (laughter) Do you want to explain that?
T: (laughter) Well, it is just that you are really setting yourself up to be knocked down every time you try to do something. You are going to have critics. You are going to be your own worst critic. You are going to always question whether you did the best job you could. You’d savage an awful lot of what you do and do it again and do it again. You have a lot of dark thoughts about what you are doing and whether it is the right thing. You are dealing with a lot of issues that reflect, I do anyway, issues that reflect what’s going on in the real world. So you spend a lot of time dwelling on that and it can be self-destructive.
S: Here’s a little aside how do you feel about the town you grew up in, Sterling, Illinois?
T: It’s a good place to be from.
S: Sterling Silver, the castle, is a very nurturing place.
T: Yeah, it responds very well to the King…
S: It keeps him safe. Have you been back to Sterling?
T: The Sterling that I grew up in doesn’t exist anymore for all intents and purposes. I’ve been back there. I go back because my parents still live there, so I go back once in a while. It holds a lot of fond memories and it was a good place to be growing up in when I was a boy, but it is not the same anymore. It has undergone terrific economic changes. It’s economic base of support has changed considerably. A lot of it has been bulldozed back into the earth, so it has changed quite a bit.
S: I want to talk a little bit about the destructive side of being a write. How does that side of you deal with the tremendous amount of praise that your books have received?
T: Oh I don’t know, I don’t tend to take most of that seriously. (laughter).
S: How can you not? Here’s some quotes: “Brooks keep’s the story going at full gallop.” “A wonderfully heartstopping series…”
T: I think people are paid to say those things.
S: Reviewers are paid to say these things about books, but which books they say them about is up to them.
T: I am a writer who writes to be read first and foremost. I am a commercial fiction writer so I like the idea that people buy these books and read them. I don’t spend much time worrying about their critical acclaim. I want people to read my books and I want them to come away saying `Wow that’s a great book.’ That’s very important. I try to focus on that part of it and I do appreciate the letters I get from people who are not paid reviewers but who have read a book and the book has really made some kind of a difference to them because that’s what effected me growing up and still affects me as a reader. I would still like to find a book that just knocks my socks off. Somebody who really speaks to the things that concern me and will write the kind of story that makes me think wow I wish I could have written that story.

S: Do you respond to mail from your readers?
T: Oh always, I always write back.
S: So we should encourage people to write to you c/o of Del Rey Books.
T: It takes a while sometimes for me to get back to them. It can take 30 to 60 days, depending on where I am and how long it takes the mail to get to me. But I answer all my own mail still.
S: In a recent People Magazine article the writer has quoted you as saying that you are just a little peeved that you are not a media darling.
T: (laughter) yeah, those People people!
S: And the article goes on to quote, “If I could just get the kind of courage that John Grisham gets.”
T: Yeah, don’t we all wish that?
S: Well, I don’t know… Do you really wish that?
T: Well, I do. The commercial side of me wishes it. The rational human being side of me says, what, are you nuts. I still like the idea I can go almost anywhere and not be recognized and that’s good. I lead a normal life. On the other hand I am always looking for a way to get other people to try the books and find new readers. You reach a certain point where it is really hard to do if you don’t get some kind of media support.
S: So you’re a self-admitted commercial writer. You said in the People magazine article, and I quote, “I kind of like the fact that my characters exist in people’s imaginations and I wonder if my books would lose something by putting them on the screen.” After the success of Jurassic Park, Rising Sun, The Firm and Pelican Brief, do you still feel that way?
T: That’s a good question. I’ve been asking myself that very question lately. On the one hand I’m concerned that if I sold the movie rights that they would destroy the story in some way. Once you sell it you don’t own it anymore and the movie people are going to do what they are going to do with it. On the other hand there is no denying the marketing effect that making a movie of a writer’s books have and we can talk about Michael Crichton, John Grisham and now Anne Rice with Interview With The Vampire. Certainly if you can get a movie made it opens a lot of potential doors for book sales that you couldn’t reach otherwise. There’s a whole other crowd out there that`s difficult in reaching in the absence of having that movie made. It’s a tradeoff of one to the other. Grisham said a good thing one time in an interview he did where they asked that very question. They asked him what control did he have and he said, `I look at it this way. When I sold the movie rights I didn’t ask to have any control. They made the movie. If it’s a good movie it’s to their credit. On the other hand they don’t take credit for what I do on my books.’ Maybe that’s the way to look at it.
S: After selling four New York Times bestsellers to the movie industry I’m sure he has a little more control than he did.
T: Who has ever done that? I mean his track record—there isn’t anybody else out there. This has been an interesting couple of years of firsts with what Grisham did with 4 of his 5 books that are in print and what Robert Waller has done with the Bridges of Madison County and now Slow Waltz at Ceader Creak.
S: We spent an interesting Summer watching the Best-seller list, counting the number of Grisham titles verses the number of Crichton titles.
T: Crichton is the the one who interests me because the selling of Jurassic Park brought all of his old books back on the Best Seller list. What a feat that is. It’s a great thing for Ballantine to have accomplished and a terrific thing for the author. There are a lot of ways that you can parlay that kind of thing into sales and it would be a great thing to do.
But, you know it is a little hard to gripe. I’ve had such great success overall. I feel a little weird sitting here saying, well, but I want more, more, more.
S: I understood that you had sold the movie rights to The Sword.
T: Early on but I got it back fortunately. That was the thing that really set me off on this question because the people who bought the rights redid the storyline and made it into a piece of science fiction with genetic mutation and computers. It was really scary. They completely altered the story and after that I was very gun shy about going back to the movie people.
S: With the release of Jurassic Park, not to beat a dead dinosaur to death, there seems to be renewed interest in science fiction, fantasy and speculative fiction. I have a few stats here: 52 million people watch science fiction programming weekly, ll million bought a science fiction book in the past l2 months, 8 million people in the U.S. have rented a science fiction video in the last month. With numbers like this, why then do you also see a categorization of science fiction? Why do you think Jurassic Park came out as fiction rather than science fiction?
T: Well I think that science fiction and fantasy have always been considered to be a category fiction. If you have something come out of that field that is successful like Jurassic Park then it is not science fiction anymore.
S: It is!
T: No, it is something else. There has always been that kind of transformation. Well we have science fiction and then we have so on and so forth. There has always been that makeover. Fantasy, for example, outsells science fiction something two or three to one on the book field it is quite a bit stronger. I don’t know what to say about that except there is certainly a reticence on the part of the reading public in general and the movie going public in particular to read either fantasy or science fiction unless there is some particular author that they like or a particular book that catches their fancy. I would certainly say Jurassic Park was one of those. It was a great idea.

S: transcription unfinished
Originally published in Cryptych Magazine.
